43.653493 -70.195478
First Image
Image 1Image 2Image 3Image 4
Image 5Image 6Image 7Image 8Image 9Image 10Image 11Image 12Image 13Image 14Image 15Image 16Image 17Image 18Image 19Image 20Image 21Image 22Image 23Image 24Image 25Image 26Image 27Image 28Image 29Image 30Image 31Image 32Image 33Image 34Image 35Image 36Image 37Image 38Image 39Image 40Image 41Image 42Image 43Image 44Image 45Image 46Image 47Image 48Image 49Image 50Image 51

Listed by Portside Real Estate Group, Susan Lessard. (207) 899-9567

MLS Source logo

59 New Island AvenuePortland, ME 04108

Active Under Contract
$925,000
3
1
1,266 SqFt

Perched at the top of Whitehead Street, this charming year-round home enjoys one of the most scenic outlooks on Peaks Island, with sweeping views toward Cushing Island. Dotted with vintage cottages and gently sloping toward Hadlock Cove and Picnic Point, Whitehead Street captures the timeless coastal character that makes this island a Casco Bay favorite. With the shoreline just steps away, walks to the water become part of daily life. A welcoming covered porch sets the tone for relaxed island living, presenting the perfect perch to enjoy sea breezes and the vibrant neighborhood atmosphere. Inside, the thoughtfully preserved and well-maintained cottage features a bright, cheerful first floor with gathering spaces. Cozy up beside the propane stove or enjoy meals with water views from the dining area. The kitchen is flanked by a first-floor bath and laundry for added convenience. A practical mudroom and flex room--currently used as a music room--allows options for a den, or formal dining room. Upstairs, the primary bedroom opens to a private balcony nestled among the trees, creating a treehouse-like retreat with views. Two additional bedrooms await family and guests. Outdoor living shines here, with a wonderful exterior shower, easy-access storage, and a large sunny corner lot enhanced by fencing, mature trees, hardy shrubs, and perennial gardens. Just a short stroll from the island's beloved ''Down Front'' shops, restaurants, and ferry landing, this special property grants convenient access to both island charm and the energy of nearby Old Port. A quick ferry ride connects you to downtown Portland while allowing you to return home to the vibrant community of Peaks Island, known for its year-round spirit, creative energy, and welcoming neighbors. OPEN HOUSE Sat., May 23, 11-1:00


FACTS & FEATURES

  • Property Type:
    Residential
  • Architectural Style:
    Cottage
  • Bedrooms:
    3
  • Bathrooms:
    1
  • Dwelling Size:
    1,266 SqFt
  • Lot Size:
    0.10 Acres
  • Lot Description:
  • Stories:
  • Year Built:
    1882
  • Interior Features:
    Shower, Storage
  • Exterior Features:
  • Parking:

    Garage or Parking Spaces:
    Features: No Driveway, 1 - 4 Spaces, On Site
  • Area:
  • Views:
    Scenic
  • Schools:
  • HOA:
  • Senior Community:
  • Heating:
    Oil, Propane, Baseboard, Hot Water
  • Cooling:
    None
  • Appliances:
    Refrigerator, Electric Range, Dryer, Dishwasher
  • Fireplace:
    Fireplace(s): 1
    Features:
  • Accessibility:
  • Security Features:
  • Foundation:
    Pillar/Post/Pier, Stone
  • Roof:
    Shingle

LOCATION


REQUEST INFORMATION

Listing Office: Portside Real Estate Group. Listing Agent: Susan Lessard. Listing ID: 1662192

Last Updated May 29, 2026 12:46 PM
Data last checked against MREIS on June 1, 2026 3:37 AM

Listing data is derived in whole or in part from the Maine IDX and is for consumers' personal, noncommercial use only. Dimensions are approximate and not guaranteed. All data should be independently verified. © 2026 Maine Real Estate Information System, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Equal Housing Opportunity logo

WE MAKE SUCCESS Simple